top of page

Job Descriptions That Attract High-Performing Talent

How to hire people who can sell — and align with your mission


Nonprofits often approach hiring with deep hope: hope that the right person will appear, hope that experience will compensate for ambiguity, hope that good intentions will translate into strong performance.


But when it comes to building a sales function — especially one that is ethical and mission-grounded — hope is not enough.


The people you hire will shape:

  • how your mission is understood

  • how partners experience your organization

  • how decisions get made

  • how work is scoped

  • how your team is protected

  • how your revenue grows (or strains)


Which means this truth matters:

Job descriptions are not paperwork.

They are leadership tools. And they are your first act of alignment.


A thoughtful job description does far more than outline tasks. It signals who you are, what you value, and how success is defined in your organization.


Let’s explore what it takes to write job descriptions that attract people who can sell without compromising your mission.


1. Start With Purpose, Not Tasks

Most job descriptions open with a list of responsibilities. But responsibilities don’t inspire — purpose does.


A strong, mission-centered job description begins with clarity:

  • What does this role make possible?

  • Who does it impact?

  • How does it serve the mission?

  • Why does this work matter now?


An effective opening sounds like:

“This role exists to help districts and schools access the right support, at the right time, in ways that honor context, readiness, and equity.”

It signals immediately: This is not traditional sales. This is thoughtful, relational, mission-protecting work.


2. Name the Real Work — Not Just the Activities

It’s easy to default to generic lines like:

  • “Build relationships”

  • “Manage a pipeline”

  • “Increase revenue”


But mission-aligned hiring requires naming the deeper work:

  • discerning readiness

  • asking thoughtful, sometimes uncomfortable questions

  • listening for meaning, not just information

  • protecting the mission by avoiding misaligned work

  • supporting leaders in making informed decisions

  • designing scopes that honor context

  • stewarding internal and external trust


These qualities help the right candidates self-identify —and help the wrong ones opt out.


3. Center Values as Core Competencies

Sales, in your organization, is not a personality trait. It is a practice grounded in discipline, integrity, and care.


Your job descriptions should highlight competencies such as:

  • Courage with kindness: can say the hard thing gently

  • Deep listening: hears readiness, risk, and nuance

  • Equity lens: honors community context and system realities

  • Judgment: knows when not to pursue an opportunity

  • Clarity-making: summarizes complexity into shared understanding

  • Boundary-setting: protects team workload and implementation quality


These competencies set a tone that says: We do sales differently here.


4. Describe Success in Human-Centered, Mission-Centered Terms

Instead of:

  • “Hit quarterly revenue targets”

  • “Grow sales by X%”


Try:

  • “Build a healthy, truth-telling pipeline grounded in readiness and alignment.”

  • “Support districts in identifying the right level of partnership for sustainable impact.”

  • “Advance our mission by ensuring scopes are realistic, equitable, and implementable.”

  • “Strengthen internal trust by communicating needs, risks, and patterns clearly.”


This helps candidates understand the kind of sales culture they are entering —one grounded in alignment, not pressure.


5. Clarify What This Role Is Not

Mission-aligned sales roles require clear boundaries.


Be explicit:


This role is not:

  • transactional selling

  • persuading unready partners

  • prioritizing revenue over readiness

  • promising work the team cannot sustain

  • viewing districts as “leads” instead of collaborators


This role is:

  • principled decision-making

  • thoughtful partnership

  • clarity-centered communication

  • respect for district realities

  • commitment to equitable, sustainable implementation


Clear boundaries attract adults who lead with integrity.


6. Tell the Truth About the Pace and Realities

Schools and districts operate within:

  • slow decision cycles

  • shifting leadership

  • political dynamics

  • budget constraints

  • readiness challenges

  • calendar barriers


Your job description should acknowledge these realities directly.


This does two things:

  1. It sets honest expectations.

  2. It attracts people who know how to work with patience, steadiness, and care.


Strong candidates will recognize themselves in this truth. Others will not — and that’s a good thing.


7. Invite People Into the Mission, Not the Metrics

The best mission-aligned sales talent often comes from people who:

  • have taught

  • have coached

  • have led in districts

  • care deeply about equity

  • understand systems

  • value integrity over pressure

Your job description should speak to the heart of that experience:

“We are looking for someone who believes in educators, honors context, listens deeply, and can guide leaders toward clarity — even when that clarity leads to ‘not now.’”

This is not typical sales. This is partnership. This is stewardship. This is mission.


The Takeaway

A job description is more than an invitation to apply.It is a signal of who you are and how you lead.


When you write job descriptions with intention, clarity, and care, you attract:

  • people grounded in equity

  • people who listen deeply

  • people who can ask hard questions kindly

  • people who steward trust

  • people who protect your mission

  • people who elevate your team

  • people who can sell with integrity


You don’t just fill a role.You build the foundation for sustainable, values-aligned revenue — and for partners who feel seen, supported, and well served.


This is how mission finds its way to the people who need it.This is how sustainable growth begins.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Gain practical tools, leadership insights, and strategy resources - twice, monthly - to help build clarity, stability, and sustainable impact.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

© 2025 McCastle Research Group

Let's connect at: hello@themccastlemethod.com

 

Tell us the topics you care about:

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
© 2025 The McCastle Method. All rights reserved.
For assistance, contact: hello@themccastlemethod.com

bottom of page